Personal Review From Customer (Unbiased)
35 of 35 people found this review helpful.
Excellent comparison of the development of Islamic and European economic law
By Steven Zoraster
I have read many books on Islam. I have read to understand why Islam conquered much and so quickly, and why not, politically and economically in the last 500 years. The relative economic decline is of interest because around 1000 AD, the Muslim world was as rich as Europe. This is the first book to provide an understanding that could be used. Not in direct conquest, but in the economy.
In "Divergence long," the author highlights two issues surrounding the Muslim law of inheritance. Islamic rule of law distribution of wealth after death among multiple heirs. This had two results. First, forced associations to be short-lived: death followed by the demands of their share of the inheritance of the heirs requires the liquidation of a company. Knowing that any death would end the partnership, Muslims tend to favor two person short-term associations. By contrast, Europeans after 1000 CE developed forms of association and the companies that could survive the death of one participant. In part, this was the adoption of primogeniture, under which a single offspring could inherit all the assets of a person in a property, business or society. At the same time, Europeans were becoming innovative about the types of trade agreements to accumulate wealth. Something like the modern corporation developed to manage the guilds, monasteries, and even cities. European leaders, desperate for money, and often only weakly in power were willing to allow independent groups with local power, in exchange for stability and the right to tax revenues or profits. These independent institutions were allowed to change its internal rules and the general objectives as circumstances change.
The second issue of "The divergence of long," Islamic explaining relative economic decline is the failure of Islam to develop something like the European corporation. Again, this relates to the Muslim law of inheritance. The Waqf, the only way Muslims could create a company that could survive its founder had to be established for one purpose and that purpose can not change. For example, a Waqf to establish a stop for caravans that could never be anything, even if the trade routes or means of transport changed. Meanwhile, as mentioned in the last paragraph, European companies could adapt to changing circumstances to reorient investment in more productive ways that circumstances have changed.
There is more to this book. I think the author has discovered something about the role of law in economic development which explains much about the relative decline of the Islamic world with regard to Europe.
Another benefit I got from reading "The divergence of long." The author argues that the codification of the rules of inheritance in Islam provided the economic laws that were superior to the alternatives available in many parts of the world at the time of the early Muslim conquest. While not arguing that this caused the rise of Islam, which suggests a reason for their initial success.
It is also noted in the book, is that the separation of church and state in Europe helped to lead innovation in Europe and stagnation in the Islamic world. This reminded me independently that the existence of canon law, the Catholic Church created to govern its internal church affairs, regardless of the laws of political entities which satisfy the religious needs of Europeans. Canon law still exists and is still used by the Church to resolve issues with the Church is the only one. (This includes the discipline of clergy, the alteration of church property, etc.) Many Protestant religions have their own versions of canon law.
Another thing: In this book I learned that Shiite and Sunni inheritance laws have a little different. I did not know that despite reading a lot about Islam.
The book was entertaing, and made me think. Not much to ask for a book about a potentially boring subject!
More The Long Divergence: How Islamic Law Held Back the Middle East [Hardcover] reviews available
Read more..
Buy Cheap The Long Divergence: How Islamic Law Held Back the Middle East [Hardcover] - Sale price!
Product Details
- Amazon Sales Rank: # 31995 in Books
- Posted: 11/15/2010
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Binding: Hardcover
- 424 pages
Features
- ISBN13: 9780691147567
- Status:
- Notes: NEW EDITOR! 100% satisfaction guarantee. Always follow up on most orders. Buy with confidence! Million books sold!

0 comments:
Post a Comment